Philippines, 12 Dec 2017
  Home >> News

 
Search Boxer:
First Name
Last Name


BOXERS                         

CURRENT CHAMPIONS 

FORMER CHAMPIONS   

RATINGS                       

FIGHT SCHEDULES        

FIGHT RESULTS            

NEWS                            

HOUSE NEWS                

FORUM                          

FIGHT GALLERIES        

TRAINERS                     

MANAGERS                    

PROMOTERS                  

BOXING GYMS               

RING CARD GIRLS        


 



Dong Secuya
Web Editor

Rene Bonsubre, Jr.
Contributing Editor

Homer D. Sayson
NBA Section Editor




Ronnie Nathanielsz

Rich Mazon

Eddie Alinea

Epifanio M. Almeda

Anthony Andales

Jason Aniel

Hesiquio Balderas

Sid Bañez

Brett Bonetti

Marlon Bernardino

Winchell Campos

Socrates Celestial

T. Chin-Te

Carlos Costa

Christopher Cruz

Rob Cruz

Jonathan Davis

Dr. Ed de la Vega

Lito delos Reyes

Gianluca (Rio) Di Caro

Edwin G. Espejo

Dennis U. Eroa

Ron Galarpe

Joaquin Henson

Oliver Iglesias

Dionis Jacobe

Ted Lerner

Salven Lagumbay

Reylan Loberternos

Mike Angel Lopez

Salvador Lopez

Joan Secuya-Medida

Ryan Medida

Rico Navarro

Rod Mijares

Manny Pacquiao

Gerry Peñalosa

Greg R. Penilla, M.D.

Gov. Manny Piñol

Dr. Allan Recto

Hermie Rivera

Emmanuel T. Rivera

Virgi T. Romano

Nicholai R. Roska

Maloney L. Samaco

Sev Sarmenta

Reynaldo Seno

Myron Sta. Ana

Atty. Danrex Joseph V. Tapdasan

Recah Trinidad

Reni M. Valenzuela

Mark F. Villanueva




 
News  


Manny no stranger to bum verdicts


PhilBoxing.com




Sen. Manny Pacquiao recently sent out a tweet of exasperation in the wake of the split draw that was announced at the end of the Gennady Golovkin-Saul Alvarez fight in Las Vegas last Saturday. While the decision was acceptable considering the close contest, what wasn’t acceptable was judge Adalaide Byrd’s score of 118-110 for the Mexican. Byrd’s insane count was the subject of scorn all over the boxing world and took away the media spotlight from the high-level of competition that both fighters delivered.

“Did they bring these judges over from Australia?” was Pacquiao’s tweet, referring to his loss to Jeff Horn by a unanimous verdict in Brisbane last July. In that bout, Horn’s dirty tricks were tolerated by referee Mark Nelson and the judges swept the Australian to the WBO welterweight throne. Judge Waleska Roldan saw it 117-111 while judges Chris Flores and Ramon Cerdan 115-113, all for Horn.

There was widespread disagreement on how the judges scored it for Horn. Claran Gallagher, writing for the London-based weekly Boxing News, said: “The wide 117-111 card handed in by Roldan was hard to fathom but the scores of 115-113 from Flores and Cerdan for the Aussie appeared more credible … this reporter scored the bout for Pacquiao 116-112, preferring the Filipino’s cleaner work.” Boxing News editor Matt Christie said: “I watched the contest twice. The first time, while listening to the BoxNation commentary, I agreed the Australian had probably done enough to take the verdict; then after a few hours’ sleep, I did so again but without any sound, and scored the contest 115-113 in Pacquiao’s favor. What hadn’t changed was my opinion that it was very hard to score.”

The Ring Magazine’s Michael Rosenthal called the scoring of the Battle of Brisbane “disturbing.” He said: “I’m still scratching my head over the Pacquiao-Horn scorecards----especially one----and those who believe Horn deserved the decision. It seemed obvious to me that Pacquiao landed more and generally better punches than Horn which is still the most important factor when scoring a fight. Horn was the more aggressive fighter but it wasn’t ‘effective aggression,’ another key criterion in scoring. He landed an extremely small percentage of his punches, compared to Pacquiao, at least to my eye. That’s why I scored it 116-112 for Pacquiao. I don’t have respect for Roldan, the judge who scored the fight 117-111, nine rounds to three, in favor of the Aussie. I haven’t added anyone for some time to my Poor Judgment Club, dedicated to those who turn in unfathomable scorecards but she definitely belongs. The 115-113 scores of the other two judges were bad enough. Roldan’s score was so ludicrous that it damaged the sport.”
****

But Rosenthal didn’t take it against Horn. “Although most people thought Pacquiao deserved the nod, Horn won,” he said. “The former schoolteacher was given almost no chance of beating the Filipino star yet, at the very least, made it a competitive fight. He employed precisely the correct strategy to give Pacquiao trouble; he roughed him up from beginning to end. The Aussie deserves credit for all of the above even if you disagree with the scorecards. He earned our respect.”

Even ring legend Bernard Hopkins couldn’t believe Horn beat Pacquiao. He said: “How does a guy like Horn, who probably didn’t win four rounds, win a unanimous decision in a 12-round fight? First, he’s fighting in his home country, Australia, even though two of the judges were American and one was from Argentina. I do know one person who is happy----Horn’s promoter.

“People asked me if I saw the Pacquiao fight and they said, ‘Well, you know, Bernard, that’s boxing.’ What? A guy getting screwed over is boxing? There are still people out there who think the mob, like guys from the 1930s and 1950s, are influencing judging and big fights. There’s too much money involved and too much at stake today for that to happen. Boxing needs to take a hard look at its judging system. The sport needs to step into the modern times.”

British welterweight champion Bradley Skeete, quoted in Boxing News, said the decision for Horn was unfair. “I had Pacquiao two rounds up,” he said. “It was close but I can see why the judges favored Horn, he was the aggressor but he wasn’t really landing. Pacquiao was more precise.” Former English title challenger Leon McKenzie, also quoted by Boxing News, said: “I think Pacquiao did win it but I can see why it went the other way. I don’t think it was a massive outrage. It was a closer fight than what people are saying.”
****

Recall that in 2004, Pacquiao was robbed of a victory by a split decision when judge Burt Clements made a mistake in scoring the first round 10-7 instead of 10-6. That was in Pacquiao’s first encounter with Juan Manuel Marquez who went down thrice in the opening round. Under boxing rules, a fighter who registers three knockdowns in a round is awarded a 10-6 score. If Clements had scored it correctly, Pacquiao would’ve won. But since he didn’t, it went down as a split draw.

In 2012, Pacquiao lost to Tim Bradley on a split 12-round decision that was considered a joke by the boxing cognoscenti. The WBO even gathered a panel of independent judges to re-score the fight from a TV monitor and the review confirmed Pacquiao deserved to win. Bradley’s “win,” however, stuck. They fought twice more with Pacquiao winning both fights and retiring Bradley for good.

There was also doubt on the credibility of judge Dave Moretti’s 118-110 score favoring Floyd Mayweather over Pacquiao in their bout two years ago. Clements and Glenn Feldman, the two other judges, scored it 116-112, both for Mayweather. Surely, Moretti’s wide margin was out of line.

So when Pacquiao reacted negatively to the draw in the Golovkin-Alvarez fight, he had the benefit of experience to justify it. He’s no stranger to bum decisions.


Click here to view a list of other articles written by Joaquin Henson.


Recent PhilBoxing.com In-House articles:

  • ALA Promotions signs Fil-Japanese amateur champion Go Hosaka
    By , Tue, 12 Dec 2017
  • Prince Ranch Boxing Signs Two More Mexican Fighters to Sugar Promotions
    By , Tue, 12 Dec 2017
  • PACQUIAO'S HANDLERS NEGOTIATING WITH MCGREGOR, BUT ARUM SAYS IT'S A NONSENSE
    By Maloney L. Samaco, Tue, 12 Dec 2017
  • UFC's Brendan Schaub Says Pacquiao Would Whoop McGregor Worse Than Mayweather
    By , Tue, 12 Dec 2017
  • RIZIN Fighting Federation World Grand Prix 2017 action to close 2017 MMA season
    By , Tue, 12 Dec 2017
  • 31st annual Ring 8 Holiday Event & Awards Ceremony: REVIEW & PICTURES
    By , Tue, 12 Dec 2017
  • Vito Mielnicki, Jr wins United States Junior National Championship in Salt Lake City, Utah
    By , Tue, 12 Dec 2017
  • FILLER STEAMROLLS INTO THE KNOCKOUT ROUNDS
    By , Mon, 11 Dec 2017
  • RESULTS FROM THE BATTLE AT GUANGZHOU
    By Rene Bonsubre, Jr., Mon, 11 Dec 2017
  • MARCH 10: A NIGHT OF CHAMPIONS IN HONOUR OF A CHAMPION
    By , Mon, 11 Dec 2017
  • RIGONDEAUX QUITS AS NO-MAS-CHENKO ALREADY MAKES FOUR SUCCESSIVE OPPONENTS SURRENDER
    By Maloney L. Samaco, Mon, 11 Dec 2017
  • Top Rank on ESPN Vasiliy Lomachenko vs. Guillermo Rigondeaux is Second Highest-Rated Boxing Telecast on Cable in 2017
    By , Mon, 11 Dec 2017
  • CHANG, OUSCHAN, LEAD THE WAY ON DAY 1
    By Ted Lerner, WPS Media Officer, Sun, 10 Dec 2017
  • PINOY CONRADO DIAZ GAINS TIE FOR FIRST AFTER BEATING AMERICAN INTERNATIONAL MASTER
    By Marlon Bernardino, Sun, 10 Dec 2017
  • MIGUEL 'MICKEY' ROMAN DEFEATS ORLANDO 'SIRI' SALIDO IN FIGHT OF THE YEAR CANDIDATE
    By , Sun, 10 Dec 2017
  • LOMA WINS BY TKO AS RIGO REFUSES TO COME OUT IN THE 7TH ROUND
    By Dong Secuya, Sun, 10 Dec 2017
  • The Palicte-Rodriguez Fight – An adventure for the Team (Photos)
    By Ed de la Vega, DDS, Sun, 10 Dec 2017
  • BAI ELORDE LOSES TO CHANIEV BY 6TH ROUND TKO IN RUSSIA
    By Dong Secuya, Sun, 10 Dec 2017
  • THE SHOWDOWN AT GUANGZHOU DEC. 10
    By Rene Bonsubre, Jr., Sat, 09 Dec 2017
  • LOMACHENKO VS. RIGONDEAUX - GREAT HISTORICAL AND IMPORTANT FIGHT
    By Maloney L. Samaco, Sat, 09 Dec 2017
  • PALICTE KNOCKS OUT RODRIGUEZ, RETAINS NABF BELT
    By Ed de la Vega, DDS, Sat, 09 Dec 2017
  • WEIGHTS FROM NEW YORK: LOMA - 129 LBS., RIGO - 128.4 LBS
    By Dong Secuya, Sat, 09 Dec 2017
  • MATTHYSSEE GUEST AT DE LA HOYA-SALGADO FIGHT
    By , Sat, 09 Dec 2017
  • DON KING’S ANNUAL CHRISTMAS TURKEY GIVEAWAY BEGINS WEDNESDAY: NINE CITIES, SEVEN STATES, FOUR DAYS
    By , Sat, 09 Dec 2017


  •  




     
    PhilBoxing.com has been created to support every aspiring
    Filipino boxer and the Philippine boxing scene in general.
    Please send comments to feedback@philboxing.com


    PRIVATE POLICY | LEGAL DISCLAIMER
    developed and maintained by dong secuya
    © 2017 philboxing.com.