Philippines, 18 Sep 2025
  Home >> News

 


BOXERS

CURRENT CHAMPIONS 

FORMER CHAMPIONS   

RATINGS                       

NEWS           

FORUM        

FIGHT GALLERIES        

RING CARD GIRLS        


 
 
News  


JUDGES ARE JUDGED


PhilBoxing.com




As a boxing judge, I feel the need to let the boxing public view a boxing match from a performing judge’s seat in one of the four sides of the square ring. This is in light of the recent criticisms directed to one of the judges in the Paulie Malignaggi-Juan Diaz first fight in Texas which Diaz won.

Paulie cried robbery. Many supported Paulie and criticized the judge who saw Diaz winning by a wide margin. It was a close fight. Hence, the disparity in the total scores of the winner and the loser shouldn’t be wide. Should it?

“Three different fights”

In a close fight with variant wide disparities in the scoring, the sarcasm of boxing reporters that the 3 judges were watching 3 different fights is, in a sense, truth.

A judge’s chair is the real ringside seat. The 3 judges occupy 3 seats placed one each at the 3 sides of the 4-sided ring. While these 3 judges watch only one fight, each of them sees only one side of the fight, his.

At a certain point during a fight, one judge might be seeing the 2 fighters facing each other. The 2nd judge might be seeing only a fighter’s back as he covers the opponent in part or in whole. The 3rd judge would be seeing the fighters from an angle different from the others’.

When a clean punch is landed at that point, the judge or judges who can see both fighters would know whom to credit the punch. The judge who sees only the back of one fighter would not see the punch unless it becomes obvious from the effect on the fighter hit. At some other instances, a judge’s view is obstructed by the referee.

These scenarios occur frequently during a fight. The 3 judges do not see a common sight. Each judge scores a round as he sees it. Certainly, in a closely contested fight, disparity in the judges’ scores is not absent.

“Review” of the fight video is not a review

After seeing a controversially scored fight on video, critics at times feel their suspicion of a botched judging confirmed. The concerned judge’s reputation is unfairly tarnished.

I was once asked if I would agree to have a “review” of the 3-round amateur boxing match involving movie actors in which I was one of the 3 judges. When the split decision result was announced in favor of the fighter from the blue corner, the crowd booed. They “judged” the fighter from the red corner deserving of the verdict. The losing boxer also showed displeasure that he lost the won fight. The stake was high. The winner gets to vie for the championship which offers a huge cash prize to the champion.

The organizers of the event said that the 3 of us judges would sit side by side this time and “review” the fight on video. Our scores in this “review” will replace the scores we submitted at the actual fight night.

I agreed provided, and my condition probably derailed the contemplated “review”, each of us 3 judges would watch the video completely taken from our respective sides of the ring during the actual fight. This way, our scores would be comparative to the previous scores we have submitted.

But to view the fight from angles different from the actual fight is not a review to a judge. If I see who landed a clean power punch which I did not during the actual fight, I am actually seeing another fight and my score this time would differ from the score during the actual fight. The decision whether to hold the “review” still hangs.

One of the recent professional fights I judged was “reviewed” by some select personnel of the supervising board in response to a protest filed by the manager of the fighter who lost via a split decision. I learned that majority of those who judged the fight on video scored the fight a draw. They were seeing only one fight.

I’m glad the split decision result was not changed. The fight on video is another fight in addition to the 3 fights each of the 3 judges watched at fight time.

A wide disparity of scores happen in close fights

I have written on this possibility in a previous article but it bears repeating since a fellow boxing judge is being widely criticized.

A closely fought round could result in a 10-9 score for the winner of the round as the judge sees it. If all 10 rounds are close and one fighter consistently has the slight advantage from the same judge’s point of view, this fighter will win the 10-round bout with a final total of 100-90. A very wide disparity open to the boxing public’s criticism. An unjustified criticism considering that the judge fairly scored the fight as he saw it.

Judges are unfairly judged

It’s easy to criticize boxing judges. But it’s not that easy to have a sound basis for the criticism. One needs to see the fight the judge saw to be in the position to rightly criticize. Critics should temper criticisms in light of the situations boxing judges are in when judging fights.

And judges should likewise understand criticisms from the boxing public however baseless these may seem. Judges are judged.


Click here to view a list of other articles written by Epifanio M. Almeda.


Recent PhilBoxing.com In-House articles:

  • Vayson aims to make history
    By Joaquin Henson, , Thu, 18 Sep 2025
  • KAIPO GALLEGOS TRAINING CAMP NOTES
    , Thu, 18 Sep 2025
  • Day Two of 2025 USA Boxing National Open Delivers 108 Action-Packed Bouts in Tulsa
    , Thu, 18 Sep 2025
  • Bryce Mills Boxes James Bernadin At del Lago Resort & Casino On Thursday, Oct. 30, in Waterloo, NY
    , Thu, 18 Sep 2025
  • Caribbean Clash Returns Friday, November 7th at Gulfstream Park Casino in Hallandale, Florida
    , Thu, 18 Sep 2025
  • VM Sotto, City Council Recognize GM Joey Antonio
    By Marlon Bernardino, , Thu, 18 Sep 2025
  • Larida is Southern Coach of the Year
    By Lito delos Reyes, , Thu, 18 Sep 2025
  • D.C. Knockout Artist Scooter Davis Signs Promotional Contract with Top Rank
    , Thu, 18 Sep 2025
  • THE PAST WEEK IN ACTION 15 SEPTEMBER 2025: Crawford Snatches Canelo's Undisputed Crown at 168 Lbs; Inoue Defeats Akhmadliev to Retain 4 Superbantam Belts; Crocker Outpoints Donovan
    By Eric Armit, , Wed, 17 Sep 2025
  • TICKET NEWS: EUBANK JR-BENN II ON SALE FROM THIS WEDNESDAY
    , Wed, 17 Sep 2025
  • “Night of Champions” Returns to Caribe Royale Resort in Orlando on September 19
    , Wed, 17 Sep 2025
  • Canelo-Crawford: The Consolidation of Boxing’s New Commercial Empire
    By Gabriel F. Cordero, , Wed, 17 Sep 2025
  • A New Era for Boxing: Canelo vs. Crawford Shatters Global Viewership Records on Netflix
    By Dong Secuya, , Wed, 17 Sep 2025
  • Crawford Not the First Lightweight to Distinguish Himself at Super Middleweight
    By Teodoro Medina Reynoso, , Wed, 17 Sep 2025
  • Kurt Scoby and Josh Popper Headline Boxing Insider Card September 19 in Times Square
    , Wed, 17 Sep 2025
  • Green and Gold 2025: Amateur Boxing’s International Gathering in Bolivia
    By Gabriel F. Cordero, , Wed, 17 Sep 2025
  • Pakistan's Sameer Khan Set to Battle for UBO Youth World Title in Brico Santig’s Sep 27 Show in Thailand
    By Carlos Costa, , Tue, 16 Sep 2025
  • SAMBO Pilipinas is Southern NSA of the Year 2025
    By Lito delos Reyes, , Tue, 16 Sep 2025
  • Kingsley “The Black Lion” Ibeh To headline historic “Legacy Nights” Inaugural Pro Boxing event in El Salvador
    , Tue, 16 Sep 2025
  • Smarts over power
    By Joaquin Henson, , Tue, 16 Sep 2025
  • HALL OF FAME FLIES FLAGS AT HALF-STAFF FOR TWO-DIVISION CHAMPION RICKY HATTON
    , Tue, 16 Sep 2025
  • Kazakhstan tops the medal table at the inaugural World Boxing Championships 2025 thanks to victory in the final bout of the competition
    , Tue, 16 Sep 2025
  • THRILLA IN MANILA GOLDEN ANNIVERSARY 13: JOE FRAZIER’S HUMBLE BEGINNINGS AS AN AMATEUR FIGHTER
    By Maloney L. Samaco, , Mon, 15 Sep 2025
  • A New King, A New Challenger: Turki Alalshikh Proposes Crawford-Benavidez While Canelo Alvarez Faces Defeat with Humility
    By Dong Secuya, , Mon, 15 Sep 2025
  • Highly Questionable Title Eliminator
    By Teodoro Medina Reynoso, , Mon, 15 Sep 2025




  •  



     
    PhilBoxing.com has been created to support every aspiring
    Filipino boxer and the Philippine boxing scene in general.
    Please send comments to feedback@philboxing.com


    PRIVATE POLICY | LEGAL DISCLAIMER
    developed and maintained by dong secuya
    © 2025 philboxing.com.