Philippines, 31 Jul 2025
  Home >> News

 


BOXERS

CURRENT CHAMPIONS 

FORMER CHAMPIONS   

RATINGS                       

NEWS           

FORUM        

FIGHT GALLERIES        

RING CARD GIRLS        


 
 
News  


Home judging ill-advised


PhilBoxing.com



WBC president Mauricio Sulaiman.

The WBC is seriously considering remote or home judging as a new protocol for fights with the pandemic still not under control. Once the situation is back to normal, the idea is to bring back judges sitting on three sides of the ring. Until then, the WBC plans to use “online” judges to score a fight from home or some remote place outside of the fight venue as a health precaution.

Aside from judges, the WBC intends to ban spectators and media from watching its sanctioned fights live. “As the WBC, we consider in a very serious and responsible way the feasibility of carrying out boxing functions behind closed doors and with TV transmission adhering to strict sanitary control and following the guidelines established by world health organizations and the guidelines of local authorities,” said the governing body in a memorandum.

The process flow for remote judging lists this sequence: First, judges access live video/audio of the fight; second, judges and supervisor log into secure WBC portal; third, judges score rounds in real-time; fourth, scores are fed to a consolidated report; fifth, supervisor transposes electronic scores to hard-copy master scoresheet; and sixth, commission and supervisor finalize results and hand to ring announcer. In the WBC’s flow chart, there is a provision for a contingency plan----“if internet connection fails, supervisor and judge will communicate via text or call between rounds to report/confirm the round scores.”

WBC president Jose Sulaiman said the proposal was made in consultation with doctors and boxing administrators, none of whom he identified. Writer Lance Pugmire said the proposal was met “with consternation throughout the sport.” Veteran boxing promoter Lou DiBella had this reaction: “We have a hard enough time judging fights normally with three (judges) sitting ringside so we’re going to do it remotely and be confident in the results? If you destroy your product in an effort to get going, what do you do to your product’s value going forward?”

The WBC justified its proposal by arguing from the viewpoint of limiting attendance in a fight venue to “essential” individuals such as the fighters, cornermen, TV staff, commission and medical personnel and sanctioning body officials. But aren’t judges “essential?” How many judges are mobilized for a boxing promotion of six to eight fights? Five? Maybe, six to rotate? Surely, the WBC can accommodate five or six more persons in its attendance sheet.

A boxing expert said the WBC will not be able to impose “online” judging in Nevada or California state athletic commissions which are autonomous in assigning judges for boxing. “It’s stupid,” the expert said. “Judges have no chance to catch COVID-19 with all the safety measures in place. There is more chance of catching the virus at Walmart where idiots are walking around with no masks, touching everything with no gloves or sanitizers. California and Nevada do it their way or the highway.”

Remote judging is ill-advised because the judges will rely on the same video, watching the same angle and restricting what otherwise they could observe from three vantage points around the ring. Home judges won’t be able to focus on things that ringside judges could, like following the progress of a cut or swelling or the mode of attack from an individual viewpoint because their perspective is limited. Online judges may be briefed via a video conference call before or after a fight as necessary but they will be detached from the live setting which could be a disadvantage. Home judges may also be exposed to external circumstances, such as hacking or influencing, not under the commission’s control because of their remote location. If the WBC’s intention is to protect the judges’ safety by isolating them from unnecessary public exposure, it should realize the risk of infection is almost nothing compared to the high risk of jeopardizing the quality of scoring a fight from home.


Click here to view a list of other articles written by Joaquin Henson.


Recent PhilBoxing.com In-House articles:

  • Vargas Speaks After Retaining WBA Bantamweight Title in Gritty Battle with Daigo Higa in Japan
    , Thu, 31 Jul 2025
  • The “ATV” Plan is set for Undefeated Bay State Junior middleweight prospect Anthony Velazquez
    , Thu, 31 Jul 2025
  • Youth High Performance Team Captain Salim Ellis-Bey Takes the World Stage With One Goal in Mind
    , Thu, 31 Jul 2025
  • Trainer Tommy Brooks Passes Away at 71
    By Gabriel F. Cordero, , Thu, 31 Jul 2025
  • Kyosuke Takami Stops Erick Rosa in 10, Becomes “The New” WBA 108 World Champion
    By Carlos Costa, , Thu, 31 Jul 2025
  • Immanuwel Aleem Smashes His Way To WBC FECARBOX Light Heavyweight Title and Inaugural DMV Belt With Spectacular 9th Round Stoppage Of Rival Demond Nicholson On Jeter Promotions Card
    , Thu, 31 Jul 2025
  • NP Bansalan will see action in Buhangin on Aug. 9
    By Lito delos Reyes, , Wed, 30 Jul 2025
  • USA Boxing Youth High Performance Team Begins Competition at 2025 Brandenburg Cup
    , Wed, 30 Jul 2025
  • Antonio Vargas Makes Weight, Set to Carry the USA Flag into World Title Showdown Against Daigo Higa in Japan
    , Wed, 30 Jul 2025
  • “The Homecoming” to be Headlined by Phenom Marco “El Tiburón” Romero Sept. 6 in Olathe, Kansas
    , Wed, 30 Jul 2025
  • Split-T Management Fighters Complete Perfect Weekend
    , Wed, 30 Jul 2025
  • Golden Boy Signs Top Mexican Light Heavyweight Prospect Yair “Manotas” Gallardo to Co-Promotional Deal with Miguel Cotto Promotions
    , Wed, 30 Jul 2025
  • 2-Time World Champion Shawn Porter Confirmed for Eighth Annual Box Fan Expo, During Mexican Independence Day Weekend, Saturday September 13, in Las Vegas
    , Wed, 30 Jul 2025
  • EVAN HOLYFIELD SET TO CONTINUE HIS COMEBACK THIS SATURDAY, AUGUST 2, AT CHRISTY MARTIN’S “MAYHEM IN MUSIC CITY 2”
    , Tue, 29 Jul 2025
  • The Boss Punches In: Joscelyn Olayo-Munoz Prepares for USA Boxing International Debut
    , Tue, 29 Jul 2025
  • Boxing Icon Don Elbaum Passes Away at 97
    By Gabriel F. Cordero, , Tue, 29 Jul 2025
  • FIGHT OF THE YEAR CANDIDATE: Andy Dominguez Defeats Byron Rojas by Split Decision To Win WBC USA Silver Light Flyweight Title on Atlantic City
    , Mon, 28 Jul 2025
  • ARMANDO MARTINEZ RABI KNOCKS OUT ALBEIRO PAREDES IN SECOND ROUND OF MAIN EVENT OF FISTS OF FURY 7 AT SEMINOLE HARD ROCK HOTEL & CASINO HOLLYWOOD
    , Mon, 28 Jul 2025
  • Hawaiian Punch: Lorenzo Patricio Closes Out Youth International Career
    , Mon, 28 Jul 2025
  • The 19th Thousand Island Cup Philippine Xiangqi Open tournament on August 3
    By Marlon Bernardino, , Mon, 28 Jul 2025
  • 3rd DC Athletics Open on Aug. 9-10 at UM
    By Lito delos Reyes, , Mon, 28 Jul 2025
  • Is Pacman Eyeing Tank? Speculation Rises for Pacquiao vs. Davis Showdown
    By Dong Secuya, , Mon, 28 Jul 2025
  • Francisco stops Dalogdog, bags Phl ‘fly’ crown
    , Mon, 28 Jul 2025
  • Boxing World Mourns the Passing of Two-Time Champion Dwight Muhammad Qawi
    By Gabriel F. Cordero, , Mon, 28 Jul 2025
  • ALEX ARIZA BACKS KENNETH LLOVER, CITES PACQUIAO-LIKE STYLE AHEAD OF AUGUST BOUT
    , Mon, 28 Jul 2025




  •  



     
    PhilBoxing.com has been created to support every aspiring
    Filipino boxer and the Philippine boxing scene in general.
    Please send comments to feedback@philboxing.com


    PRIVATE POLICY | LEGAL DISCLAIMER
    developed and maintained by dong secuya
    © 2025 philboxing.com.